Oceans and land
Somerset police dog praised for successfully tracking suspect
On the track to the moors
Initiative to improve sustainable fish labelling unveiled
Protection of grey wolves may be ended by Obama administration
RSPCA comes under fire for badger cull protests
The rain released from the parched ground that glorious earthy perfume
May's diverse wildlife finds hedgerows the perfect home
The pink-footed geese seemed restless, as if uncertain what they were doing
Study links insecticide use to invertebrate die-offs
Has the internet killed the Loch Ness monster?
Waitrose pledges to source all seafood from independently certified providers
It's the first time I've heard the chiffchaff's song this year
Edinburgh zoo's pandas help boost visitor numbers by 51%
Their bombastic majesties begin the nectar frenzy
Pandas have saved Edinburgh zoo from extinction but what for?
Insecticide spraying will be expanded to control pest caterpillar
This is the EU's best chance in a decade to reduce fish discards
Fish company investigated after salmon farm pollutes Scottish loch
Poachers kill 26 elephants at central African world heritage site
New to nature No 103: Tinkerbella nana
Sand martins dig tunnels in the dunes
World's tallest dam approved by Chinese environmental officials
Justin Bieber 'owes thousands' after leaving monkey hanging in Germany
A brief stillness before the damselfly's short life on the wing would begin
  Counting the cost: fears badger cull could worsen bovine TB crisis
"It's very hard to count an animal that lives underground and only comes out at night," says Prof Rosie Woodroffe, standing in the fresh earth strewn outside a foot-wide hole in a Cornish cattle field. "Badgers love digging," she observes, among the brambles and elders that thrive on the disturbed ground.

Below stone tors and with the salty smell of the sea in the air, Woodroffe is doing what she has done for much of the past 15 years: trapping badgers for science. "The badgers are fat this year," she says. "The wet spring means there's lots of earthworms." But a dry summer could mean four in every five cubs die, she warns, and it is uncertainties in population like these that mean she is seriously worried about the controversial badger culls due to start after 1 June.

The culls are intended to curb the rise of bovine tuberculosis: more than 37,000 cattle were slaughtered in 2012, at a cost to the taxpayer of £100m. But farmers in the pilot cull areas in Gloucestershire and Somerset have to tread a fine line: kill too many badgers and they will break the law against local extinctions of the protected animal, while killing too few means escaping badgers will spread TB even further. The problem, says Woodroffe, is the real number of badgers is hard to establish. Initial estimates were made by counting badger setts.

"This is a stupid way to count badgers," says Woodroffe. "A single sett is not meaningful for a badger because they live in social groups and use more than one sett, possibly four or five."

Initial sett-based estimates from farmers were rejected by the government, which then did its own sett survey, which came up with much higher numbers and derailed the start of the cull in October. The new government data, partly based on DNA testing of badger hair samples, lowered the numbers again.

The uncertainties are so great, says Woodroffe, that it is "perfectly plausible" that every badger in a cull zone could be killed while at the same time too few badgers were killed to meet the minimum number set by the cull licence.

Prof Tim Coulson, a zoologist at Oxford University and a member of the independent expert group advising ministers on the cull, said: "For most wild species, trying to count the number of animals in a population, if they spent a lot of time underground or roaming over large distances, is extremely difficult."

Further uncertainty comes from claims by anti-cull activists to have sabotaged the hair-snare survey by removing fur from the traps. "We wanted to muck up the count and we definitely succeeded," says Jay Tiernan of the Stop the Cull campaign. "I don't see how we didn't." The government says activist action had no impact on the population estimates, but Woodroffe says the claims do add uncertainty.

The Guardian meets Tiernan in the Somerset cull zone, where he ruefully notes that the steep-sided hills provide a good backstop for the marksmen who will carry out the cull. The former soldier, who acknowledges trespass and criminal damage convictions but denies any involvement with violence, says activists have surveyed the areas and are preparing for action.

"We are stopping the cull with the direct action, not tea and biscuits," he says. "But we condemn harassment and we condemn private property damage. I would not be happy to see a brick thrown through a window. We don't want to look like thugs or look desperate we are in a good position already. We want as much of middle England behind us as possible."

A large section of the public already is, fronted by rock star Brian May and backed by the RSPCA and others. Their 225,000-strong petition won the first House of Commons debate on the cull in which MPs voted against it. Tiernan's more direct tactic, he says, will be to scare badgers away from shooters and he has ready 150 vuvuzelas and a number of "gizmos" MP3 players linked to megaphones. "We'll be playing heavy metal like Slayer," he says.

Sixty miles away in Dorset, where a reserve cull zone is being prepared, farmer James Cossins is also concerned about badger numbers. "What's made them dig out here?" he asks, standing in a field over a pile of dirt, yards long andstudded with chalk. "I think it's overpopulation. We definitely have more badgers than 20 years ago."

Cossins, whose 2,200-acre mixed farm is adjacent to the proposed cull zone, has little doubt the 27 cattle he lost to TB caught the disease from badgers. "We are a closed herd," he says. "All our animals are bred on the farm. We very occasionally buy in a stock bull, but only from a known farm and only when fully tested for TB."

The neighbouring farms are mainly arable, so "our cows have very little contact with other cows". He adds: "It is very frustrating and demoralising: we dread every test. I've got nothing against the little furry fellows, but sitting back and doing nothing is not an option. People are at their wits' end."

Cossins is the fifth generation of his family to run the farm and his husbandry has earned a valuable "high herd health status" for his cattle. He acknowledges that past farming industry practices helped spread TB, which rose from 235 infections across Britain in 1986 to 28,541 in 2010.

"The movement of cattle in the past did make TB worse, but now that is controlled and I don't know how much tougher you could get. All the rules and regulations are loaded one way: we feel we have all these controls on the cattle but no controls on the badgers."

This is contested by John Bourne, the vet who led the government's 10-year, £50m trial of badger culling which reported in 2008 that it could "make no meaningful contribution" to curbing bovine TB. "The cattle controls in operation at the moment are totally ineffective," he says, because the tuberculin test used is not very accurate, meaning herds can often test negative even while still harbouring the disease.

"It's an absolute nonsense that farmers can move cattle willy-nilly after only two tests. Why won't politicians implement proper cattle movement controls? Because they don't want to upset farmers."

Bourne acknowledges that cattle can get TB from badgers, but says the true problem is the other way around: "Badger infections are following, not leading, TB infections in cattle."

Bourne oversaw the culling of 11,000 badgers in the trial and says it is very hard to cull quickly and effectively, even without interruptions from protesters. "You just chase the badgers around, which makes TB worse," he says. "We don't know what the outcome of the cull pilots will be but the likelihood is it's going to make things worse."Many cull opponents cite vaccination of badgers, or in future of cattle, as a better alternative. But the government's chief veterinary officer, Nigel Gibbens, says: "That is not with us now the need to control TB in cattle is with us right now. It is a very significant disease causing significant pain."

He is supported by Peter Kendall, the president of the National Farmers Union. "Farmers are doing all they can to stop their cattle from catching bovine TB and vaccination of cattle and badgers is emphatically not an alternative to controlling disease in badgers," he says. He believes a suitable cattle vaccine is too far off and badger vaccination is too expensive.

Woodroffe disagrees. Badgers can be vaccinated now the Welsh government has chosen this option in preference to culling and using volunteers could significantly reduce costs, she says. The cull risks being a costly diversion. "If you think about how long the cull policy has taken, the government could have been much further forward with vaccination."

With his glossy black cows pressing in around him, Cossins considers the future. "It may be that culling doesn't work and then we'll have to look at alternatives. In an ideal world I would vaccinate our cows."
Japanese firm stops selling endangered whale pet treats
Comment of the week: why rewilding 'the wild' isn't so wacky
Humaneness of badger cull to be judged on noise of dying animals
Jean-Jacques Annaud: 'People who make films are in danger every day'
An oystercatcher rises surreptitiously, suggesting that it has a nest nearby
Short-haired bumblebee queens hoped to boost UK population
Badger vaccination 'would be cheaper to implement than cull'
Atlantic puffin population is in danger, scientists warn
Jellyfish surge in Mediterranean threatens environment and tourists
Lord's Resistance Army funded by elephant poaching, report finds
Why did dinosaurs evolve feathers?
Why the celebrity status of badgers is a problem
'Badger-friendly' milk to be sold in just three UK supermarkets
Labour fails in attempt to stop badger cull with Commons vote
Orange tip butterflies are so fragile, yet survive violent rainstorms intact
A cetti's warbler bursts into violent exclamation
Tammy the anteater to greet fans in London Zoo late-night walkabouts
Cod stocks recover after years of overfishing
Are some animals more worth saving than others?
Thai police discover 14 albino lions in warehouse near Bangkok
White lion breeding at UK wildlife parks linked to 'canned hunting'
Is the rise in antibiotic use on farms a threat to humans?
Stop using birdsong apps, nature reserve tells visitors
Cheetahs 'more powerful than a motorbike'
Meet Ming, the panda who left China to boost Britain's wartime morale
Badger cull activists can 'bend the rules' during protests, say police
RSPB accused of hypocrisy for killing hundreds of birds on its reserves
Wolf walking in Cumbria: the new leaders of the pack
Marine Harvest agrees to limit pesticides and seal killings
Schmallenberg vaccine available to UK farmers this summer
Cat wars break out in New Zealand
Racing pigeon sold for record £260,000
Most UK species in decline, wildlife stocktake shows
Hedgehogs are disappearing fast gardeners to the rescue
I've often seen bees infested with mites, but rarely one so heavily laden
Government licensed secret buzzard egg destruction, documents reveal
Hedgehogs have everything they need in this garden
China reports rise in humans encountering wild Siberian tigers
New to nature special: the top 10 new species
Zoo keeper mauled by tiger 'broke safety rules'
Industry, fires and poachers shrink Sumatran tigers' last stronghold
The swift is a bird that screams of the Earth's intricate interconnectedness
Tiger that killed zoo worker 'dragged her into its enclosure'
Culls risk illegally exterminating badgers, animal expert warns
Counting the cost: fears badger cull could worsen bovine TB crisis
My manifesto for rewilding the world
Ban Ki-moon to warn UN security council of dangers of wildlife trafficking
Beaver kills man in Belarus
GM 'hybrid' fish pose threat to natural populations, scientists warn
The beaver from Belarus and other deadly animals
Ants in Germany repeatedly ring woman's doorbell
A nightly procession of pheasants, ducks, deer and badgers in the garden
Visit Statistics